Republic of the Philippines

Supreme Court

Manila

Summary of Voting

Title	Philippine National Railways v. Ethel Brunty and Manuel M. Garcia	Ponente	J. Callejo, Sr.
Docket No.	GR No. 169891	No. of Participating Justices	5
Date of Promulgation	November 2, 2006	Unanimous Decision (Yes/No)	Yes

Concurring Justices		Comments e.g. separate opinion (SO), joined SO, reservations
1	CJ. Panganiban	Joins ponencia
2	J. Ynares-Santiago	Joins ponencia
3	J. Austria-Martinez	Joins ponencia
4	J. Chico-Nazario	Joins ponencia
5	-	-
6	-	-
7	-	-
8	-	-
9	-	-
10	-	-
11	-	-
12	-	-
13	-	-
14	-	-

Dissenting Justices		Comments e.g. dissenting opinion (DO), joined DO
1	-NA-	-NA-
2	-	-
3	-	-
4	-	-
5	-	-
6	-	-
7	-	-

Justices Not Participating		Reason e.g. on official leave
1	-NA-	-NA-
2	-	-
3	-	-
4	-	-
5	-	-
6	-	-
7	-	-